Nobody tells you that sharing the wrong thing at the wrong time can kill your business. One person will say you’re oversharing while another thanks you for finally being real. So what are you actually supposed to share when you’re building a business? And more importantly, when?

The Relatability Paradox

Here’s something most marketing advice won’t tell you: what the rest of the world considers “too much information” might be exactly what your audience needs to hear.

Recording content while dealing with allergies from visiting family over the holidays? Mentioning that your period started and you’ve got cramps? Admitting you’re supposed to be on camera but feel too puffy and stuffy so you’re going audio-only instead?

To most people, that’s TMI. To moms running businesses? That’s Tuesday.

The difference between sharing that builds connection and sharing that tanks sales isn’t about being more polished or less honest. It’s about understanding what’s relatable to your specific audience versus what’s just noise.

Think about it this way: you were pumped about doing something—creating content, launching an offer, showing up live—and then life happened. Your period hit. You got sick. Bad news came through. Whatever emotional or physical curveball got thrown your way made that thing on your schedule suddenly feel impossible.

That’s the human experience your audience is living too. And when you share those moments, you’re not oversharing—you’re creating connection.

What Makes You Relatable vs. What Makes You Unreachable

This is the foundation of effective content that actually converts: sharing the parts of your life that make you feel like a real person to your audience.

Consider the difference between these two scenarios:

Scenario A: You share that you’ve never cleaned your own house, had someone nurse your baby at night so you never lost sleep, and have a driver who takes your kids to school.

Scenario B: You share that you live in an expensive area but make coffee in a $20 coffee maker, mixing different brands you’ve perfected over time until you can’t stand drinking coffee anywhere else.

The first scenario creates distance. It makes people think: “Well, how would you know what my life is like?”

The second scenario creates connection. It shows you’ve reached certain levels of success while still being a regular human who gets excited about small things.

The goal is sharing things that make your audience think: “Oh my gosh, she gets it. She’s like me.”

This is why mom memes go viral in what we call “dark social”—the DMs and private group chats where we share things with each other. We see something and immediately go: “YES. That’s me. I totally get it.”

The Critical Framework: Wounds vs. Scars

Here’s where most people building businesses get vulnerability completely wrong, and it costs them customers without them even realizing it.

There’s a massive difference between sharing from a wound and sharing from a scar. Understanding this distinction will change everything about what you put out into the world.

What Is a Wound?

A wound is:

• Open, raw, and actively painful
• Makes you cry or feel intense emotion when you talk about it
• Has no lessons learned yet—only pain, guilt, confusion, or grief
• Still happening or just happened
• Needs processing, not teaching

When you share from a wound, people want to give you a hug. They want to tell you everything’s going to be okay. They don’t want to bother you or burden you with their problems. And critically—they don’t want to buy from you because they’re worried you can’t handle it.

Sharing wounds leads to people backing away from you, not learning from you.

What Is a Scar?

A scar is:

• Healed with clear distance from the event
• Comes with frameworks, systems, and lessons you can teach
• Something you can discuss without shame or overwhelming emotion
• A story that makes people want to learn from you, not just comfort you
• Has actionable takeaways

When you share from a scar, people think: “I want to get through things like that just like she did. Teach me your ways.”

This is the hero’s journey—you chose a quest, went down that path, it was really hard, and now you’re on the other side with wisdom to share.

The Alice in Wonderland Trap

Most of us don’t experience a hero’s journey where we deliberately chose our path. We experience what’s called the Alice in Wonderland story—we fell into a hole we didn’t choose.

You didn’t choose for your parent to get cancer. You didn’t choose for someone to pass away. You didn’t choose to get divorced. Those things happened to you.

And in the process of healing from them, you start sharing online. You start talking about it. And then you think: “Well, now that I’m here, I should monetize this.”

This is what happens when you monetize your healing instead of monetizing your healed.

The problem? If you’re still in the healing process, you don’t yet have the scars and systems to show other people how to navigate it. You’re still figuring it out yourself.

A Real Example: When Sharing Too Soon Backfires

When a parent passes away, the grief hits in unexpected ways. In that raw, wounded state, sharing everything online—the pain, the guilt about the relationship that could have been, the resentment about choices made—feels like necessary processing.

And the response you get feels good in the moment. People tell you they love you. They say it’s going to be okay. They offer comfort and support.

But here’s what also happens: they stop buying from you.

Not because they don’t care. Because they don’t want to bother you. They feel like you can’t handle anything else on your plate. They back away out of kindness—and your business suffers.

The alternative isn’t better. Ignoring grief completely, saying “business goes on as usual,” and pushing through leads to six months of basically sabotaging your own sales. You might not get rid of your team, but you stop actually selling. You go through the motions while your business slides into debt.

The lesson—the scar that comes from this experience—takes time to form. Sometimes five years. And the lesson is this: when life happens and grief hits, don’t ignore it. Your business will suffer if you don’t recognize it and change how you’re operating to give yourself the space you need.

That’s something you can teach with confidence and conviction once enough time has passed. But in the moment? It’s just a wound that needs tending, not marketing.

How to Know When Something Is Ready to Share

You know something has become a scar when the shame goes away.

When you can say it out loud and think: “Yeah, other people deal with this too. I’m not the only one.”

Consider the difference between these two internal experiences:

Still a wound: “I’m ashamed that my business isn’t ten times bigger. I’m ashamed that I have limiting beliefs about being a CEO. I’m scared to have a big team. Being a single mom makes me nervous about overhead. I would never say this out loud.”

Now a scar: “I kept my business smaller than I wanted for years because of fear and limiting beliefs. So many moms do this exact thing. Here’s what I learned about why we do it and how to move past it.”

The shame has to go away first. Then you need to analyze it: What did I learn? What can I teach? What advice can I give so people want to learn from me, not just comfort me?

When You Can Share Something Fresh: The Exception

There’s one scenario where you can share something that just happened without it being a wound you’re monetizing: when you already have the framework to handle it.

Example: Having a panic attack while driving through mountains with your kids in the car sounds like a wound. It’s scary. It’s happening in real-time. But if you already have a system for handling panic attacks—if you know to tell your kids what’s happening, ask them not to ask if you’re okay but to tell you it will be okay, move to the right lane, slow down, not worry about cars passing you, and get help afterward—then you’re teaching from a scar even if the event is recent.

The wound isn’t the panic attack itself. The wound would be not knowing how to handle it.

When you share that story with clear lessons built in, people don’t want to hug you. They think: “Thank you for saying this out loud. I’m forwarding this to other people who need to hear it.”

That’s the difference.

The Two Questions to Ask Before Sharing Anything

Before you post, record, write, or share anything online, ask yourself these two critical questions:

Question 1: Is This Relatable to My Specific Audience?

Not relatable to everyone. Not what most people would find appropriate. Relatable to the people you want to serve and sell to.

Will this make them feel seen, understood, and less alone? Will they think “yes, that’s me too” or will they just be confused about why you’re sharing it?

What’s relatable varies wildly by audience. For moms building businesses, talking about getting distracted while creating content, managing priorities between what you want to do and what needs your time, or showing up even when you feel like garbage—that’s all relevant.

For a different audience, those same shares might feel random or irrelevant.

Question 2: Is This a Scar or a Wound?

Can you share lessons and frameworks, or are you still crying when you talk about it? Will people want to learn from you, or will they just want to give you a hug and leave you alone?

If it’s still a wound, you have two choices:

1. Don’t share it publicly yet. Share it with your inner circle—the people whose job it is to love you and hold space for you without needing to learn anything.
2. If you must share it, make it clear you’re processing, not teaching. Don’t try to monetize or build a business around something you’re still actively healing from.

Building a Business on Scars, Not Wounds

After a decade of building Boss Mom and coaching thousands of moms in business, the patterns become clear. The most successful content—the content that actually converts—comes from a place of healed wisdom, not active pain.

When Boss Mom first started, it wasn’t about teaching moms how to be better moms. That was the healing happening in the background—figuring out how to be a mom while still being a woman with dreams and desires. That needed community and camaraderie, not monetization.

What got taught and sold? Marketing. Sales. Business strategy.

Years later, with a decade of scars and systems and frameworks developed from watching thousands of moms navigate these waters, a book about motherhood and business makes sense. Not because the wound is fresh, but because the lessons are clear.

You can’t teach with confidence about something you’re still figuring out. You can share your journey, sure. But building a business requires frameworks that come from scars, not wounds.

Your Inner Circles vs. Your Influence Circles

Just because you have a platform online doesn’t mean the whole world becomes your inner circle.

You need different circles of people:

Your inner circle: People who let you cry. Who love and accept you no matter what. Who don’t need to learn from you—they just need to be there for you. You can sit in silence together. They hold space for your wounds.

Your influence circle: People you can potentially impact, teach, and serve. They need to see your scars with lessons attached. They need frameworks and wisdom, not active processing of pain.

Understanding which circle you’re speaking to changes everything about what you share and when you share it.

The Real Goal of Vulnerable Sharing

The goal isn’t to share less. It’s not to be more polished or less authentic. It’s not to hide your humanity or pretend life isn’t messy.

The goal is to understand what connects, what teaches, and what timing makes the difference between building trust and inadvertently pushing people away.

When you get this right, you wake up knowing exactly what to share with the world. It feels easy instead of agonizing. And it’s the content that actually gets you more sales while feeling more real and authentic.

Because here’s the truth: you can post on social media every single day for the rest of your life and nothing happens if you don’t understand these dynamics. But when you understand what to share (the relatable human moments your audience is living too) and when to share it (from scars with lessons, not from wounds seeking comfort), everything changes.

---

“You know it’s a scar when the shame goes away. When you can share the lessons learned in a way that makes people want to learn from you, not just hug you—that’s when you know you’re ready.”

---

Vulnerability isn’t about sharing everything. It’s about sharing the right things at the right time to the right people. Master that, and you’ll build a business that feels authentic while actually converting—because your audience will trust that you understand them, and more importantly, that you’ve walked the path ahead of them and have the map to share.

Ready to master the balance between vulnerability and strategy in your business? Join Boss Mom+ to connect with thousands of moms who are navigating this exact journey—learning what to share, when to share it, and how to build businesses that feel real while actually making money.